The 7 checks (in Apple's order)
- Family Sharing and a Child Account: the child must have their own Child Account inside your group, not share an account.
- Update every device in the group so settings sync.
- The child is signed in with their Child Account on their device.
- You're in the child's contacts (the organizer or a parent/guardian), so requests can be sent.
- The child's own contact card has the right name and Child Account email or phone number; requests travel through Messages.
- Focus: allow time-sensitive notifications, or turn Focus off and test.
- Purchase Sharing and the purchase account: Settings > Family > your name > Purchases > Apple Account for Purchases must be the same account you use for Family Sharing.
All from Apple Support.
"Unable to Ask Permission"
This message means the child is signed in with iCloud and media accounts that aren't linked to each other. Fix the Apple Account the child uses for purchases, then try again (Apple Support).
Ask to Buy greyed out
Depending on the child's age and country, Ask to Buy and app restrictions are on by default and can't be turned off until 18, which shows as a setting you can't change (Apple Support).
Requests stopped after iOS 27
The new parental controls need iOS 27 on every family device, and Apple prompts you to review the old settings (Apple). A device left on iOS 26 is the usual suspect.
While you fix it
On a device you share with your child, Cloak locks the apps that matter with its own password, so a broken request flow doesn't leave everything open.