What "pending" means
Apple: if your device is offline, the remote erase process begins the next time it's online (Apple). A thief who keeps it off or in airplane mode delays the erase, not cancels it.
What to do while it's pending
- Don't remove the device from Find My, even after erasing; Apple says to keep it there, and Activation Lock keeps working after a remote erase (Apple, Apple).
- Change your Apple Account password and the passwords of email and banking apps.
- Call your carrier to suspend the line.
- Keep the police report number for insurance.
Erase or Lost Mode?
Lost Mode keeps the phone locatable and locked with your passcode; erase wipes it. If you still hope to find it, use Lost Mode first; once it's erased, you may no longer be able to locate it. If Find My was off before it was stolen, neither is possible (Apple).
Next time
The grab is the moment that matters. WTMP, armed on a table, a charger or in a pocket, sounds a loud siren the moment the phone is moved, unplugged or pulled out, and its connectivity trigger goes off if the network is cut. Only your passcode stops it.