Guide · Philos

30 philosophical questions to ask, by topic

Quick answer

Good philosophical questions to ask have no single right answer but force a reason: “Would you plug into a machine that gave you perfect happiness?” Below are 30, grouped by topic (self, ethics, meaning, mind, love), each with the philosopher or thought experiment behind it, so the conversation can go deeper.

Updated 3 min readGambit Studio

Use without installing →Free in your browser, no sign-up

About the self

  1. If every plank of a ship is replaced, is it the same ship? Are you the same person you were ten years ago? (Ship of Theseus, Plutarch)
  2. What do you know for certain? (Descartes)
  3. Would you rather be loved or understood?
  4. Which of your beliefs have you never questioned? (Socrates)
  5. Are you your memories?
  6. Is there a self behind your thoughts? (Buddhism, Hume)

About right and wrong

  1. Would you pull a lever to save five people if it killed one? (the trolley problem)
  2. If you could be invisible, would you still be good? (Ring of Gyges, Plato's Republic)
  3. Is lying ever right? (Kant said no)
  4. Do we owe more to family than to strangers?
  5. Is it fair to judge people from the past by today's values?
  6. Can a good person do a bad job well?

About meaning and happiness

  1. Would you plug into a machine that gave you perfect experiences for life? (Nozick's experience machine)
  2. If you knew you would die in a year, what would you change? (memento mori)
  3. Is a happy life the same as a good life? (Aristotle)
  4. Can Sisyphus be happy? (Camus)
  5. Would you live your life again exactly the same, forever? (Nietzsche's eternal recurrence)
  6. What would make your life wasted?

About mind and reality

  1. How do you know you're not dreaming? (Descartes, Zhuangzi's butterfly)
  2. Could a computer ever feel?
  3. Do we have free will if everything has a cause?
  4. Is math invented or discovered?
  5. Would you trust your senses if you'd lived in Plato's cave?
  6. Does a tree falling in an empty forest make a sound?

About love and friendship

  1. Are friends of pleasure, use or virtue? Which are yours? (Aristotle)
  2. Can you love someone you don't respect?
  3. Is jealousy a sign of love or of ownership?
  4. “If you would be loved, love”: is that true? (Seneca, Letter 9)
  5. Should you tell a friend a painful truth?
  6. What do you owe someone you used to love?

How to keep the conversation good

  • After any answer, ask “why?” once, then “what if…?” once.
  • Agree to argue the side you don't hold for one round.
  • Stop at three questions; the best ones take 20 minutes.

For the cave question, see the Allegory of the Cave in 5 steps.

Write your answers next to the quotes

Philos, Gambit Studio's iPhone app, lets you write your own quotes and reflections, next to a Quote of the Day and 160+ quotes you can filter by mood: anxious, frustrated, lost, tired and more. Your favorites stay one tap away.

Sources

  1. Seneca, Moral Letters to Lucilius, translated by Richard M. Gummere (Standard Ebooks)
  2. Plato, The Republic, Book VII, translated by Benjamin Jowett (Project Gutenberg #1497)

Frequently asked questions

What people ask most about this, answered with the source.

What is a good philosophical question to ask?
“Would you plug into a machine that gave you perfect happiness for life?” It tests whether you value experiences or reality.
What is the Ship of Theseus question?
If every part of a ship is replaced over time, is it still the same ship? It is used to ask what makes a person the same over time.
What philosophical questions can couples ask?
Can you love someone you don't respect? Is jealousy love or ownership? What do we owe each other when we disagree?
PhilosStoic Quotes: Seneca, Socrates
Use without installingGet