With a phone stolen from car, mark it as lost in Find My first, then report the break-in: many police forces take vehicle burglary online, like San Francisco's. Call your carrier to block it and check what your policy covers. Who Touched My Phone (WTMP), by Gambit Studio, alarms when an armed phone is lifted.
Updated 2 min readGambit Studio
Steps
Mark the iPhone as lost at icloud.com/find (Apple).
Photograph the damage and list everything taken.
Report it: SFPD, for example, lists vehicle burglary (property stolen from a vehicle) as a report you can file online (SFPD).
Call your carrier to suspend the line and block the IMEI.
Claim: phone insurance, home or renters cover, or the car policy, depending on what each covers.
Prevention
AMTA's first rule: never leave the phone lying around in public, and don't leave it in a car (AMTA). A phone mount or charging cable visible from outside says there's a phone to take.
Next time: an alarm before it walks off
Most of these steps happen after the phone is gone. WTMP works before: arm it and set the iPhone down, and if someone picks it up, unplugs it, pulls it out of your pocket or cuts the network, a loud alarm goes off, even in silent mode, with a flashing screen and flash. Stopping it takes your passcode, and the log keeps the time and the trigger.
WTMP protects while it's armed and the screen is open. It sounds the alarm before the phone leaves your hands; it doesn't track a phone that is already gone, and it takes no photos.