Reporting it to the NYPD
From the NYPD's reporting page (NYPD):
- In immediate danger: 911.
- After you report a crime or lost property, request a Verification of Crime/Lost Property report; it's not the same as the complaint report.
- The application is available at any police precinct, Housing police service area or Transit district, and requests can be made online or by mail.
- There's no fee for it since May 5, 2019.
Before you report
- Mark it as lost at icloud.com/find (Apple).
- Get the IMEI and serial number from account.apple.com > Devices (Apple).
- Call your carrier: Verizon, AT&T, T-Mobile.
Tips for the subway and sidewalks
- Put the phone away as the train doors open.
- Step back from the curb before using it; scooters and bikes ride close (snatching).
- If Find My shows where it is, give that to officers instead of going yourself.
An alarm for tables, trains and pockets
WTMP's On the Desk scene sounds a loud alarm if the phone is lifted from a table; In Pocket alarms if it's pulled from a pocket or bag. The siren plays even in silent mode, with a flashing screen and flash, and only your passcode stops it.
If it happens anyway: iPhone stolen abroad: what to do.