Steps
- Mark it as lost first; Lost Mode alone already locks it.
- In Find My (another device) or icloud.com/find, select the iPhone and choose Erase This Device.
- If it's offline, the erase begins the next time it's online (Apple).
- Leave it in Find My. Removing it removes Activation Lock and makes resale easier.
When to wait
- If you can still see its location and police may act on it.
- If you have AppleCare+ with Theft and Loss: you can erase, but keep it in Find My until the claim is approved.
After the erase
Your Lost Mode message keeps showing even after the erase (Apple), and Activation Lock still needs your Apple Account password to reactivate the iPhone. Change your Apple Account password and review the devices on your account.
Next time: an alarm before it walks off
Most of these steps happen after the phone is gone. WTMP works before: arm it and set the iPhone down, and if someone picks it up, unplugs it, pulls it out of your pocket or cuts the network, a loud alarm goes off, even in silent mode, with a flashing screen and flash. Stopping it takes your passcode, and the log keeps the time and the trigger.