Guide · Walk

Rucking vs walking: calories and which to choose

Quick answer

Rucking vs walking: rucking is walking with a weighted backpack, and the load raises the cost. On the flat, a 40 lb pack takes a 2.5 mph walk from 3.5 to 4.8 METs, about 37% more energy; on 3-10% hills with 21-40 lb it reaches 7.5 METs, double a moderate walk.

Updated 3 min readGambit Studio

Important: this guide summarizes official guidelines and published studies and is not a substitute for advice from a doctor. If you have a chronic condition, are pregnant, feel pain when walking or have been inactive for a long time, talk to your doctor before changing your routine.

Calories: rucking vs walking

ActivityMET130 lb155 lb180 lb205 lb
Walking 2.5-2.9 mph, no load (treadmill)3.5147176204232
Walking 2.5 mph, 40 lb pack (treadmill)4.8224267310353
Walking with a day pack, level3.5147176204232
Hills 3-10%, 21-40 lb load7.5383457531604
Hills 5-20%, 20+ lb load, brisk10531633735837
Walking 3.0-3.4 mph, no load3.8165197229260

Active calories in 60 minutes. MET values from the 2024 Compendium (walking with loads, climbing hills with loads) (Compendium 2024).

Rucking vs a weighted vest

Both add load; a vest spreads it around the trunk, a pack sits on the back and shoulders. In a controlled study, a vest of 15% of body weight raised calories about 12% on the flat at 2.5 mph (ACE), which matches the modest gain the Compendium shows for a pack on level ground. Hills are where the load really counts. See weighted vest walking.

How to start rucking

  1. Start with 10% of your body weight or less (15-20 lb for many people) in a snug backpack.
  2. Walk 20-30 minutes on flat ground, 2 times a week.
  3. Add 5 lb or 10 minutes every 1 to 2 weeks; add hills last.
  4. Keep the weight high and close to your back, and stop if your back or knees hurt.

Which to pick

  • Walking: easiest to do every day; the best base.
  • Rucking: more work per minute, useful if your time is short or you are training for hiking.

Where the Walk app helps

Walk estimates your resting calories from your weight, height, age and sex and adds the active calories from your steps, so you see your total daily energy expenditure (TDEE), not only the walk. With an Apple Watch it pulls the measured active calories and exercise minutes. You can set a daily calorie goal and watch the ring fill.

Sources

  1. 2024 Adult Compendium of Physical Activities: Walking
  2. ACE: Improve Walking Workouts with Weighted Vests (ACE-commissioned study, University of New Mexico, 2014)

Frequently asked questions

What people ask most about this, answered with the source.

Does rucking burn more calories than walking?
Yes. A 40 lb pack raises a flat walk's cost by roughly a third; with hills it can double.
How much weight should I ruck with as a beginner?
About 10% of body weight or less, then build up slowly.
Is rucking better than walking for fat loss?
It burns more per minute, but what matters most is total weekly activity and diet. Walk more often first, add load later.
Rucking vs hiking: what is the difference?
Hiking is walking on trails; rucking is walking with a weighted pack, anywhere. A loaded hike is both.
WalkSimple Pedometer & Weight Loss
Get