What the study found
University of New Mexico researchers had 13 untrained women walk at 2.5 mph at 0%, 5%, 10% and 15% grades with no vest, a vest of 10% of body weight and a vest of 15% (ACE):
- Flat ground: a 10% vest did not raise energy use significantly; a 15% vest raised it about 12%.
- 5-10% incline: a 10% vest raised it about 13%, and going to 15% added nothing more.
- At a 15% grade, a heavier vest made no difference.
They noted that vests are a poor fit for some conditions, including arthritis, severe osteoporosis and COPD, and recommended checking with a doctor first.
How heavy a vest for walking?
| Body weight | Vest at 5% | Vest at 10% | Vest at 15% |
|---|---|---|---|
| 130 lb | 6 lb | 13 lb | 20 lb |
| 155 lb | 8 lb | 16 lb | 23 lb |
| 180 lb | 9 lb | 18 lb | 27 lb |
| 205 lb | 10 lb | 20 lb | 31 lb |
| 230 lb | 12 lb | 23 lb | 34 lb |
Start near 5% for a couple of weeks, then 10%. The study's flat-ground effect needed about 15%.
Calories with and without a vest
| Activity | MET | 130 lb | 155 lb | 180 lb | 205 lb |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Treadmill 2.5 mph, flat, no load | 3.5 | 147 | 176 | 204 | 232 |
| Treadmill 2.5 mph, flat, 40 lb load | 4.8 | 224 | 267 | 310 | 353 |
| Walking 3.0-3.4 mph, flat, no load | 3.8 | 165 | 197 | 229 | 260 |
| Hills 3-10% grade, 21-40 lb load | 7.5 | 383 | 457 | 531 | 604 |
Active calories in 60 minutes. MET values from the 2024 Compendium (walking with loads) (Compendium 2024).
Where the Walk app helps
Walk estimates your resting calories from your weight, height, age and sex and adds the active calories from your steps, so you see your total daily energy expenditure (TDEE), not only the walk. With an Apple Watch it pulls the measured active calories and exercise minutes. You can set a daily calorie goal and watch the ring fill.