Why not go yourself
- AT&T: don't try to recover it yourself, even if you can track it; file a police report (AT&T).
- Vodafone: don't use a "find my phone" feature to track and confront the alleged thief (Vodafone).
- Three and Telstra: share the location with the police instead (Three).
What to do with the location
- Screenshot Find My with the address and time; locations change.
- Mark the iPhone as lost so it locks and shows your number (Apple).
- Call the police and give the screenshot, the serial number and the IMEI.
- Play a sound only if police are there or ask you to.
- Don't erase it yet if police may still use the location; once erased, Find My can't track it the same way.
If police won't go
Keep it in Find My (Activation Lock stays on), block the IMEI with your carrier and claim insurance with the report number. Don't answer messages from the thief.
Next time: an alarm before it walks off
Most of these steps happen after the phone is gone. WTMP works before: arm it and set the iPhone down, and if someone picks it up, unplugs it, pulls it out of your pocket or cuts the network, a loud alarm goes off, even in silent mode, with a flashing screen and flash. Stopping it takes your passcode, and the log keeps the time and the trigger.