What still works while it's off
- Marking it as lost: it appears online and in Lost Mode once it's turned on and connected to Wi-Fi or cellular (Apple).
- Remote erase: if the device is offline, it begins the next time it's online.
- Activation Lock: it stays on as long as you don't remove the iPhone from Find My (Apple).
- The Find My network: Vodafone notes an iPhone can report its location through the Bluetooth of other iPhones nearby (Vodafone).
Steps
- In Find My, note the last location and time.
- Mark it as lost now so it locks the moment it reconnects.
- Turn on Notify When Found if you see it.
- Call the carrier to block the IMEI and report it to the police.
Why thieves turn it off
To keep it offline. Turning off Control Center on the Lock Screen makes airplane mode harder to reach (how), and airplane mode on a stolen phone covers the rest.
Next time: an alarm before it walks off
Most of these steps happen after the phone is gone. WTMP works before: arm it and set the iPhone down, and if someone picks it up, unplugs it, pulls it out of your pocket or cuts the network, a loud alarm goes off, even in silent mode, with a flashing screen and flash. Stopping it takes your passcode, and the log keeps the time and the trigger.